Board Thread:Setting Things Up/@comment-4023106-20130624230635/@comment-4023106-20130625161903

Yeah, pairings might be difficult. Is there any way to provide a dropdown box? If not, I suppose it's not too big a chore to do it manually. I don't have any particular opinions about how we do "genre" either, so long as it works! Just whatever you think is best.

For reviews... we have the comment or talk section, and we have the story page itself. Comments would of course be easier, but then it would be difficult for the best reviews to be recognized as such. Having reviews on the page itself would be convenient for readers, but it wouldn't really allow for discussion, and it could get messy fast. I'd lean towards the comment section, but I don't know if there's a character limit.

How about this:

Everybody posts comments and reactions and reviews of all kinds in the comment section. Story pages have a section containing anchor links to the best review-quality comments. Readers can jump directly to those reviews through the anchor links, or they can browse the comment section as a whole to get a broader impression.

And -- looks like there's no character limit! Not a significant one, anyway.